You have to be adventurous to try the shot, but the cocktail isn’t too chilling! (Anybody else want to write these intros? I’m embarrassing myself here.)

Shot: Batty Bat, after the sleep demon in one of the, if not the, best episodes of the show.

1/2oz each bourbon and brandy. Almost knocked out Peacock.

Cocktail: Cemetery Mudslide, referring to a spell that went horribly wrong.

1oz each dark rum, coffee liqueur, and Irish cream; dash chocolate bitters. Shake over ice and strain into a cocktail glass. Any resemblance to the drink known as a Mudslide is purely intentional.

The shot could’ve been better, but hey, the show could’ve been better too. Check out our thoughts on both, plus a draft of favorite pop culture witches, on our Chilling Adventures of Sabrina podcast!